Do foot orthotics actually work?

The honest short answer

Foot orthotics are one of the most common things people are offered for sore feet, knees, and shins. They are also one of the most talked-about — often with big promises attached. So it is worth asking plainly: do they actually work?

The honest answer is "sometimes, for some problems, for some people — and less dramatically than the marketing suggests." The research does not support orthotics as a cure-all, and it does not support the idea that a pricey custom pair is automatically better than a simpler off-the-shelf one. But for certain uses the evidence is genuinely encouraging. This piece walks through what orthotics are, what the studies do and do not show, the custom-versus-store-bought question, and who is qualified to sort out whether they make sense for you.

What foot orthotics actually are

A foot orthotic (or orthosis) is an insert that sits inside your shoe. The goal is to change how your foot is supported and how load moves through your foot, ankle, knee, and hip as you stand and walk.

There are two broad families. Prefabricated (also called off-the-shelf or over-the-counter) orthotics are made in standard shapes and sizes; you buy them ready to wear, sometimes with minor trimming. Custom orthotics are made from a cast, scan, or detailed measurement of your own foot, then built to a prescription. Custom devices generally cost much more, and they are often described as the "gold standard" — a claim the evidence looks at more skeptically than you might expect.

What the evidence does — and doesn't — support

Orthotics are not one treatment for one problem. They get used for many different conditions, and the evidence is uneven across them. Here is the picture use-case by use-case.

Heel pain (plantar fasciitis). This is one of the most common reasons orthotics get recommended. A systematic review and meta-analysis of 20 trials found that foot orthoses were not clearly better than sham (dummy) inserts or other standard care for improving pain and function in plantar heel pain [1]. In the same analysis, custom-made orthotics did not outperform prefabricated ones [1]. That does not mean an insert is useless — many people find one helpful as part of a broader plan alongside stretching — but on the current evidence, an orthotic on its own is unlikely to be the whole answer for heel pain.

Knee pain (patellofemoral pain, the "runner's knee" around the kneecap). Here the evidence is a bit more positive in the short term. A randomised trial of 179 adults found that prefabricated orthoses produced more improvement than flat dummy inserts at six weeks, with a "number needed to treat" of about four — meaning roughly one in four people got an added benefit they would not have had otherwise [2]. Importantly, the orthoses worked no better than physiotherapy, and by one year all groups had improved to a similar degree [2]. So for this kind of knee pain, an off-the-shelf orthotic is a reasonable option that may help sooner, not a uniquely powerful one.

Preventing overuse injuries in active people. This is where orthotics look most promising. A systematic review and meta-analysis of runners (12 studies, more than 5,000 people) found that those using foot orthoses had fewer lower-limb injuries — a risk ratio of about 0.6, or roughly a 40% lower injury rate, rated moderate-quality evidence [4]. A separate randomised trial gave prefabricated orthotics to naval recruits during basic training; the orthotic group had fewer injuries (18% versus 26%), about a 34% reduction — but this did not reach statistical significance, and the orthotic group also reported more minor problems like blisters and arch pain [3]. So prevention is a real and interesting signal, strongest for running, but not a guarantee, and the inserts can cause their own small irritations.

Rheumatoid arthritis and other conditions. For foot problems in rheumatoid arthritis, a systematic review concluded the evidence is limited and largely inconclusive, with no clear winner among orthotic types beyond a modest effect on forefoot pressure [5]. For people with diabetes at higher risk of foot ulcers, a Canadian health-technology review found the picture mixed but noted that some clinical guidelines do recommend custom orthotics for selected higher-risk patients [6]. These are specialised situations that call for individual medical assessment rather than a store-bought fix.

Across all of these, a fair summary is this: orthotics are not magic, the average effects are usually modest, and they tend to work best as one part of a plan that also includes exercise, footwear, and load management.

Custom versus off-the-shelf: the honest comparison

This is the question that costs people the most money, so it deserves a straight answer. For several of the most common uses, custom orthotics have not been shown to work better than prefabricated ones. The heel-pain review found no advantage for custom over prefab [1]. The Canadian health-technology review reached the same conclusion for plantar heel pain and noted that custom devices were generally less cost-effective, given the much higher price for little or no measurable clinical gain [6].

That does not make custom orthotics pointless. For certain feet — unusual shapes, specific medical conditions, higher-risk diabetic feet, or problems that have not responded to simpler options — a custom device built to a prescription may be the right call [6]. The takeaway is not "never go custom." It is that "custom" is not automatically "better," and a trial of a good off-the-shelf insert is often a sensible, lower-cost first step to discuss with a professional.

Who assesses and prescribes orthotics in Canada

Because the right answer depends so much on your specific feet and goals, who assesses you matters. In Canada, several regulated professionals work with orthotics, and their roles overlap.

• Podiatrists and chiropodists are regulated foot-care practitioners who can assess foot problems, diagnose, and prescribe orthotics (podiatrists also have a broader surgical scope in some provinces).
• Canadian Certified Pedorthists (C. Ped (C)) specialise in assessing lower-limb mechanics and designing, fitting, and adjusting orthotics and footwear. Their governing body, the College of Pedorthics of Canada, requires a proper assessment — history, weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing evaluation, biomechanical testing, gait analysis, and footwear review — before any device is made [7].
• Physiotherapists often assess foot, knee, and hip problems and may recommend orthotics as one part of a program built around exercise and activity changes; the knee-pain evidence above suggests physiotherapy and orthotics can be similarly helpful [2].

A good assessment should explain why an orthotic is being suggested for your specific problem, what it is meant to change, whether an off-the-shelf option is worth trying first, and what else (exercise, footwear, gradually rebuilding activity) belongs in the plan.

The bottom line

Do foot orthotics work? For some conditions and some people, yes — the short-term knee-pain evidence and the injury-prevention signal in runners are genuinely encouraging [2][4]. For others, like heel pain on its own, the benefit over simpler care is unclear, and the effects overall tend to be modest rather than dramatic [1]. And a more expensive custom device is not reliably better than a well-chosen off-the-shelf one for many common uses [1][6].

What no article can do is examine your feet, confirm what is actually causing your pain, and judge whether an orthotic fits your situation — or whether your time and money are better spent elsewhere. That is exactly what a regulated professional is for. If sore feet, knees, or shins are bothering you, a physiotherapist, podiatrist, chiropodist, or certified pedorthist can assess you properly, tell you honestly whether an orthotic is likely to help, and build a plan around it. Use this summary to ask sharper questions; let a qualified professional make the call for your feet.

Ready to take the next step?

Two ways to connect with regulated care near you:

Tell us what’s going on — answer a few quick questions and we’ll connect you with clinics in your area. Get connected →

Prefer to look yourself? Browse regulated care clinics near you — locations, contact details, and booking where available. Find clinics near you →